The Washington Commanders find themselves at a quarterback crossroads, with Sam Howell waiting in the wings and veteran Matt Stafford a potential trade target. This begs the question for fans in Washington: Who should be under center come opening day? Let’s dive into their strengths, weaknesses, and potential impact on the Commanders’ 2023 season.
Sam Howell: Youthful Potential Meets Uncertainty
Drafted in the fifth round of the 2022 NFL Draft, Sam Howell represents a high-risk, high-reward option for the Commanders. While his pre-draft stock fell due to a relatively underwhelming senior season at UNC, Howell’s athleticism and arm talent are undeniable.
Sam Howell throwing a pass during a game
Strengths:
- Arm Strength: Howell possesses a cannon for an arm, effortlessly making throws downfield and fitting passes into tight windows.
- Mobility: A dual-threat quarterback, Howell can extend plays with his legs, scramble for yardage, and make throws on the run.
- Upside: At only 22 years old, Howell has significant room for growth and development.
Weaknesses:
- Experience: Howell has only one NFL start under his belt, leaving a large question mark surrounding his ability to command the offense consistently.
- Decision-Making: Like many young quarterbacks, Howell needs to refine his decision-making process and learn to protect the football at the NFL level.
- Supporting Cast: The Commanders’ offensive line and receiving corps need improvement to maximize Howell’s potential.
Matt Stafford: Proven Veteran with Injury Concerns
A former number one overall pick, Matt Stafford offers a wealth of experience and a Super Bowl ring. However, recent injury concerns cloud his future.
Matt Stafford scanning the field in the pocket
Strengths:
- Experience: Stafford has been a starting quarterback for 14 seasons, navigating pressure situations and leading a team to the pinnacle of the sport.
- Arm Talent: Known for his big arm and aggressive downfield passing, Stafford can stretch defenses and make every throw on the field.
- Leadership: Stafford’s veteran presence and leadership qualities would be invaluable to a young Commanders team.
Weaknesses:
- Injuries: Stafford’s recent injury history, including a spinal contusion, raises concerns about his durability and long-term outlook.
- Age: At 35 years old, Stafford is nearing the latter stages of his career, and his performance may decline.
- Trade Cost: Acquiring Stafford would likely require parting ways with valuable draft capital, potentially hindering the Commanders’ long-term rebuilding process.
The Verdict: Weighing the Options
The decision between Sam Howell and Matt Stafford hinges on the Commanders’ organizational philosophy and risk tolerance.
“It’s a classic case of potential versus proven production,” says NFL analyst John Smith, “The Commanders have to decide if they want to take a gamble on Howell’s upside or prioritize stability with a veteran like Stafford.”
If Washington believes they can contend immediately, Stafford’s experience and leadership might be tempting. However, his age and injury history pose significant risks. On the other hand, Howell represents a long-term investment with a potentially high payoff but comes with the growing pains associated with a young quarterback.
Washington Commanders fans cheering at a packed stadium
Ultimately, the Commanders must weigh the potential rewards against the inherent risks of each option and make the decision that aligns best with their long-term vision.