When it comes to drafting running backs in fantasy football, the decision between Nick Chubb and Austin Ekeler can leave even the savviest manager scratching their head. Both players have consistently delivered elite production in recent seasons, making them tantalizing options for your fantasy squad. So, how do you choose between these two fantasy football powerhouses? The answer, like most things in fantasy, depends on your individual team needs and draft strategy.
Breaking Down the Case for Nick Chubb
Nick Chubb is the epitome of a workhorse running back. He’s the engine that drives the Cleveland Browns’ run-heavy offense, consistently racking up yards and touchdowns.
Here’s what makes Chubb a fantasy stud:
- Volume King: Chubb is a volume monster, averaging over 20 touches per game over the last three seasons. This consistent workload provides a high floor for fantasy production, even in tough matchups.
- Rushing Dominance: Chubb is a pure runner with a knack for breaking tackles and churning out yards after contact. He’s finished top-five in rushing yards in each of the past three seasons, showcasing his elite ability to move the chains.
- Touchdown Upside: While not known for his receiving prowess, Chubb finds the end zone with regularity. He’s a threat to score every time he touches the ball near the goal line.
However, Chubb does come with some drawbacks:
- Limited Receiving Role: The Browns’ run-first offense limits Chubb’s involvement in the passing game. While he’s capable of catching passes, he’s unlikely to put up significant receiving yards or receptions.
- Injury History: While not injury-prone, Chubb has missed time in the past due to injury. His physical running style increases the risk of future injuries.
Examining the Appeal of Austin Ekeler
Austin Ekeler is the definition of a dual-threat running back. He’s a dynamic playmaker who excels as both a runner and receiver, making him a fantasy football unicorn.
Here’s why Ekeler is a fantasy force:
- Receiving Weapon: Ekeler is arguably the best pass-catching running back in the NFL. He’s a matchup nightmare for linebackers and consistently puts up wide receiver numbers in PPR leagues.
- Big Play Potential: Ekeler is electric in space and can take it to the house on any given play. His speed and elusiveness make him a threat to score from anywhere on the field.
- Involved in a High-Powered Offense: The Los Angeles Chargers boast one of the league’s most explosive offenses, led by quarterback Justin Herbert. This offensive firepower provides ample opportunities for Ekeler to shine.
However, Ekeler’s fantasy stock isn’t without its concerns:
- Workload Management: The Chargers have shown a willingness to manage Ekeler’s workload, especially towards the end of the season. This can lead to some frustrating weeks for fantasy managers, particularly in crucial playoff matchups.
- Durability Concerns: Ekeler’s smaller stature and reliance on speed and agility have led to some durability concerns in the past.
The Verdict: Chubb or Ekeler?
So, who should you draft? The answer depends on your risk tolerance and what you’re looking for in a running back.
Draft Nick Chubb if:
- You prioritize a high-floor, consistent producer.
- You’re comfortable with limited receiving upside.
- You value touchdown potential and a strong rushing attack.
Draft Austin Ekeler if:
- You covet a high-ceiling, game-breaking talent.
- You value receiving production and PPR upside.
- You’re comfortable with some level of workload management.
Ultimately, both Nick Chubb and Austin Ekeler are elite fantasy running backs capable of winning you a championship. The best choice for your team depends on your individual needs and draft strategy.
