The age-old fantasy football dilemma: choosing between two seemingly equal players. Today, we’re tackling the kicker conundrum, specifically, should you draft Jake Elliott Or Harrison Butker? Both have established themselves as consistent performers in the NFL, leaving fantasy owners with a tough decision.
While kickers may not hold the same glamorous appeal as quarterbacks or wide receivers, their contributions can be the difference between a win and a loss in the fantasy realm. So, let’s dissect the careers of Elliott and Butker, comparing their stats, consistency, and upside to help you make an informed decision for your fantasy draft.
A Statistical Showdown: Analyzing the Numbers
When comparing kickers, field goal percentage naturally takes center stage. Since joining the league in 2017, Jake Elliott boasts an 84.5% success rate, successfully converting 146 of 173 attempts. Butker, joining the league the same year, holds a slightly higher career field goal percentage at 89.1%, making good on 176 of 198 attempts.
Looking at extra point percentage, both players display remarkable consistency. Elliott maintains a 93.8% success rate on extra points, while Butker holds a near-perfect 97.5%.
Delving deeper, we can analyze their performance from longer distances. While both kickers demonstrate accuracy, Butker seems to hold a slight edge in field goal attempts beyond 50 yards.
Consistency is Key: Examining Week-to-Week Reliability
Beyond raw statistics, consistent point production is crucial for fantasy success. Examining their fantasy points per game averages over their careers, Butker edges out Elliott slightly. However, both have proven capable of delivering double-digit fantasy performances in favorable matchups.
An aspect to consider is the performance of their respective teams. While both the Philadelphia Eagles and Kansas City Chiefs have been offensive powerhouses in recent years, consistently strong offensive performances generally translate to more scoring opportunities for kickers.
The Verdict: Who Earns the Fantasy Roster Spot?
The Elliott versus Butker debate boils down to a close call. Butker, with his slightly higher field goal percentage and track record of fantasy production, might seem like the obvious choice. However, Elliott’s consistency and the potent Eagles’ offense cannot be overlooked.
Ultimately, the decision hinges on your draft strategy and risk tolerance. If you prioritize a slightly higher ceiling and proven track record, Butker is your guy. If you’re comfortable with a slightly lower floor but a kicker attached to a high-powered offense, Elliott presents excellent value.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
Q1: Does draft position matter for kickers?
Generally, it’s advisable to wait on drafting a kicker until the later rounds, prioritizing skill positions first. However, if both Elliott and Butker are available in the later rounds, snatching one up could provide excellent value.
Q2: Should I consider the opposing defenses when making my kicker selection?
Absolutely! Facing a porous defense significantly increases a kicker’s fantasy ceiling for that week.
Q3: What other factors should I weigh when choosing between two kickers?
Weather conditions on game day, injury reports, and even coaching tendencies can influence a kicker’s performance.
Need More Fantasy Football Insights?
Choosing the right kicker is just one piece of the puzzle. For more fantasy football advice, tips, and strategies, contact us:
Phone Number: 0902476650
Email: [email protected]
Address: 139 Đ. Võ Văn Kiệt, Hoà Long, Bà Rịa, Bà Rịa – Vũng Tàu, Việt Nam.
Our dedicated team is available 24/7 to answer your questions and provide expert insights. Dominate your fantasy league with VNG Game – your ultimate source for all things gaming.