The question of protective gear in hockey, particularly regarding cages versus visors, often sparks debate. While the NHL doesn’t permit full cages for players already in the league, the rules are a bit more nuanced than a simple yes or no. Let’s delve into the regulations surrounding face protection in the NHL and the reasoning behind them.
NHL Rules on Face Protection: Cages vs. Visors
The NHL mandates that all players entering the league since the 2013-2014 season must wear visors. This rule aims to minimize facial injuries from errant sticks, pucks, and skates. However, players who were already active in the NHL before the rule change have the option to forego facial protection altogether.
While cages offer more comprehensive protection, they are not permitted for players who have already debuted in the NHL. This rule stems from a combination of factors, including tradition, aesthetics, and player preference.
NHL Player Wearing a Visor
Why No Cages for Existing NHL Players?
-
Tradition and Image: Hockey has a long history where facial hair and expressions were on full display. The introduction of visors, let alone cages, was initially met with resistance by some who felt it detracted from the game’s rugged image.
-
Player Preference: Many players find cages cumbersome, affecting their vision and breathing. Visors, being less intrusive, are generally preferred.
-
Grandfather Clause: The NHL often implements new safety rules gradually, respecting the preferences of established players. Hence, the “grandfather clause” allows those who played before the mandatory visor rule to maintain their choice of protection.
Benefits and Drawbacks of Cages
While cages aren’t allowed for most NHL players, they offer undeniable benefits:
Benefits:
-
Maximum Protection: Cages offer the most comprehensive facial protection, safeguarding against high-impact shots and potential skate blades.
-
Peace of Mind: For players concerned about facial injuries, cages provide a sense of security, allowing them to focus on the game.
Drawbacks:
-
Visibility: Cages can obstruct peripheral vision, potentially impacting a player’s ability to track the puck and opponents.
-
Communication: Some players find that cages muffle sound and make communication on the ice more difficult.
Hockey Cage and Visor Comparison
FAQs about Cages in the NHL
1. Can NHL players wear cages if they have a medical reason?
While the NHL has provisions for players returning from injury, they usually involve wearing a visor temporarily until they are fully recovered. The league generally does not make exceptions for cages outside of the mandatory visor rule for new players.
2. Are cages common in other hockey leagues?
Cages are more common in youth hockey and some amateur leagues where safety is prioritized over aesthetics and tradition.
3. Have any NHL players successfully petitioned to wear a cage?
While there have been instances of players advocating for cages, particularly after serious injuries, the NHL has not made any exceptions to its rule regarding established players.
Conclusion: Safety and Tradition in the NHL
The NHL grapples with balancing player safety with the traditions and preferences that have shaped the game. The mandatory visor rule for new players demonstrates a commitment to enhancing safety measures, while the “grandfather clause” acknowledges the league’s history and player choice. Ultimately, the decision of whether to wear facial protection, within the league’s guidelines, rests with individual players.
