The debate between drafting Harrison Butker Or Jake Elliott in fantasy football often sparks heated discussions among fantasy owners. Both kickers have proven themselves as reliable scorers, making the decision of who to draft a tough one. This article will delve deep into the stats, strengths, and weaknesses of both kickers to help you make an informed decision for your fantasy team.
Harrison Butker kicking a field goal
Harrison Butker: The Consistent Performer
Harrison Butker, the Kansas City Chiefs’ placekicker, has been a mainstay in fantasy football lineups for years. His consistency and accuracy have earned him a reputation as one of the league’s top kickers.
- High-Powered Offense: Playing for a team with an explosive offense led by Patrick Mahomes gives Butker ample opportunities to rack up points. The Chiefs’ ability to move the ball down the field consistently puts Butker in prime field goal range.
- Accuracy: Butker boasts an impressive career field goal percentage, consistently ranking among the league’s best. His accuracy from long range also makes him a valuable asset.
- Home Field Advantage: Arrowhead Stadium, known for its passionate fans, can be a challenging environment for opposing kickers. However, Butker thrives in this atmosphere, further bolstering his fantasy value.
Jake Elliott celebrating a successful field goal
Jake Elliott: The Clutch Performer
Jake Elliott, the Philadelphia Eagles’ placekicker, has consistently proven his ability to deliver in crucial moments.
- Strong Leg: Elliott is known for his strong leg and ability to make long field goals. This makes him a valuable fantasy asset, particularly in leagues that award bonus points for kicks over 50 yards.
- Clutch Performances: Elliott has a knack for making big kicks when it matters most. He’s delivered several game-winning field goals throughout his career, showcasing his composure under pressure.
- Improving Offense: With a young and developing offense in Philadelphia, Elliott could see an increase in scoring opportunities as the team continues to grow.
Head-to-Head Comparison
| Category | Harrison Butker | Jake Elliott |
|---|---|---|
| Team | Kansas City Chiefs | Philadelphia Eagles |
| Career Field Goal Percentage | 90.6% | 84.5% |
| Career Longest Field Goal | 62 yards | 61 yards |
| 2022 Fantasy Points | ||
| 2022 Average Fantasy Points Per Game |
The Verdict
Both Harrison Butker and Jake Elliott are excellent fantasy kickers with the potential to be top scorers at their position. The decision of who to draft ultimately depends on your personal preferences and league settings.
If you prioritize consistency and high floor, Harrison Butker is the safer choice. His situation in Kansas City’s explosive offense provides him with a wealth of scoring opportunities.
If you’re looking for a kicker with a high ceiling and the potential for game-changing kicks, Jake Elliott is an intriguing option. His strong leg and history of clutch performances make him a threat to score from anywhere on the field.
Ultimately, the best advice is to draft the kicker you feel most comfortable with and who fits your draft strategy.